• Delivery Days

    Tuesday & Friday

  • Delivery Area

    East of Shinnecock Canal

  • Delivery Charge

    Free (Temporarily Waived)

  • Minimum Order

    $50 (Reduced Rate)

Grid View:

Zucchini Bread

$12.75 / each

Zucchini Bread (No Nuts)

$12.75 / each

Eli's Ciabatta (Large)

$7.00 / each

Eli's French Baguette

$5.00 / each

Eli's Health Loaf

$7.00 / each

Blue Duck Three Berry Pie, 6"

net wt. 16oz
$12.00 / each

Blue Duck Wild Blueberry Crumb Pie, 6"

net wt. 16oz
$12.00 / each

Blue Duck Peach Crumb Pie, 6"

net wt. 16oz
$12.00 / each

Blue Duck Apple Crust Pie, 6"

net wt. 18oz
$12.00 / each

Milk Pail Apple Pie (Crumb Top)

net wt. 2lbs 8oz
$26.00 / each

Milk Pail Apple Pie (Crust Top)

net wt. 2lbs 2oz
$26.00 / each

Anke's Chocolate Chip Cookies

net wt. 5oz
$8.00 / bag

Anke's Chocolate Oat Crunch Cookies

net wt. 5oz
$8.00 / bag

Anke's Ginger Oat Crunch Cookies

net wt. 5oz
$8.00 / bag

Mary's Chocolate Chip Cookies

locally made
$10.00 / bag

Mary's Ginger Molasses Cookies

locally made
$10.00 / bag

Eli's Blondie

3.5 oz
$4 / each

Eli's Brownie

3.5 oz
$4 / each

Eli's Pecan Square

3.5 oz
$4 / each
Showing 1 to 24 of 35 (2 Pages)

You are about to leave DELIVERY

Any items in your cart not available in the other stores will removed.

CONTINUE

This store is for Delivery orders only.

If you would like to pick up your order in Amagansett click here to order from the Amagansett Farm Stand Store.

If you would like to pick up your order in Montauk click here to order from the Montauk Market.

Your account login is the same for all stores but check out is separate. Please be sure you are at the correct store before shopping.

Thank You, The Balsam Team

This store is for Amagansett Farm Stand pick up orders only.

If you would like to pick up your order in Montauk click here to order from the Montauk Market.

If you would like your order delivered click here to order from the Delivery Store.

Your account login is the same for all stores but check out is separate. Please be sure you are at the correct store before shopping.

Thank You, The Balsam Team

This store is for Montauk Market pick up orders only.

If so, please visit the Amagansett Farm Stand Store.

Rather Have your Order Delivered?

If so, please visit the Delivery Store.

Please start your order at the store you intend to check out at. Your account login is the same for all stores but check out is separate.

Thank You, The Balsam Team